Sarah is wondering why you stopped reading? |
Etymology
can be both fun and frustrating. Fictional
writers get to do pretty much whatever they want—provided they don’t break the
reader’s willing suspension of disbelief.
That’s
the trick.
Recently,
I reviewed a draft blurb for another author who used a line similar to this:
When Sarah and
George touch, they can cause great destruction, ruin buildings, or build them
back up.
Nothing
inherently wrong with that. It reads
like a young adult, superhero genre story in a contemporary setting.
Except
it’s not.
George knows why you stopped, and doesn't care. |
The
author explained the setting—outside of the blurb—as a story set 90,000 years
ago. Understand, she’d done her
due-diligence—Sarah is Biblical and means “princess” while George comes from
the Greek Georgos and means farmer.
The
problem with this is Sarah and George are common, contemporary names, and with
no other clues as to the setting, they don’t speak to an ancient fantasy-type story. As the writer who has done all the research
on names and dates and so forth, this is all justified. The problem comes when a reader picks up the
book expecting a coming-of-age story (with superpowers!) and gets a fantasy-themed
tale about a princess and a farmer.
Despite
advances in technology, writers still can’t address every reader’s concerns as
they read through the story.
So
while the reader must supply a willing suspension of disbelief, the writer must
take every measure to not break that trust—even if it means changing the heavily
researched names of the characters.
No comments:
Post a Comment